Yes, and…
Yes, but…
I’m not disagreeing with you. In fact I believe you are mentioned something truly valuable, only a few people can grasp.
Level 1: Not that many people know Web3
Level 2: Not that many people know Kleros
Level 3: Not that many people know the incentives of the jurors
Level 4: Not that many people know the incentives of the jurors and when it can go astray
Welcome to Level 5
We need to go deeper…
Jurors vote for the majority.
- you get what you incentivize
- show me the incentive and I will tell you the outcome
The incentive is to behave coherently, therefore they will vote for the majority, full stop.
I tried to come up with an example where majority is not right = … … … … … … … (please come up with ideas here)
There is an incentive to be the “unpopular juror”:
- Vote as a juror against the majority
- Case goes to the next round
- Your decision is upheld
- Financial incentive
NOTE: If you are that “unpopular juror” - you should publish your thinking process, upload it as evidence, convince others.
(Kleros has no KYC, same human can be a juror, plaintiff, defendant, using multiple ETH addresses = feature not a bug)
So far, there was not a single case that was obviously wrong. There were some cases:
- technicalities
- nuances
- wording
- loopholes
- multiple possible interpretations
- astroturfing and attempts to spread misinformation
(and Kleros remained resilient at all times)
When I look at FTX SBF legal fees, I think Kleros is 100x more cost-efficient and 10x faster.
(gathering evidence, voting, funding appeal = it takes a few weeks)
(interesting thread about one of the biggest, most controversial cases)
(LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO)
Another controversial case: #82 GRID PLUS Badge – Challenge | Heliast
It was about 3rd party audit. Project form ConsenSys ecosystem and ConsenSys audit wasn’t considered 3rd party.
More thoughts:
My forum post about definition of “fairness”:
I want jurors to consider what is fair, not just coherent.
Director of resaerch:
More Discussion
Telegram link: Telegram: Contact @kleros
